The SHO Locate Requirement and Close-Out Rule: How the SEC Regulates Short Selling

The SHO locate requirement, set out in Rule 203 of Regulation SHO adopted by the SEC, bars a broker from accepting or executing a short sale order unless it has first borrowed the security, entered into a good faith arrangement…

5 minutes

Dark purple illustration of a golden clock surrounded by light rays, coins and a rising stock chart over mountains, evoking the SHO locate requirement and short sale close-outs.

The SHO locate requirement, set out in Rule 203 of Regulation SHO adopted by the SEC, bars a broker from accepting or executing a short sale order unless it has first borrowed the security, entered into a good faith arrangement to borrow it, or has reasonable grounds to believe the security can be borrowed and delivered on the settlement date. This requirement is documented in the text of the rule itself, codified at 17 CFR 242.203 of the eCFR. It is paired with a second obligation, the close-out rule, which forces the close-out of a failure to deliver within precise timeframes.

Why the SEC created this locate obligation

Regulation SHO imposes four general requirements on short sales of equity securities, as the SEC’s Trading and Markets division recalls in its questions and answers document: a marking requirement, a short sale price test circuit breaker, a locate requirement and a close-out requirement. The logic behind the locate requirement is simple: a broker cannot transmit a short sale order without reasonable assurance that the security can actually be delivered to the buyer on the settlement date. Without this prior check, the risk of non-delivery, known as a failure to deliver, rises mechanically.

What Rule 203 exactly says about locating a security

The text of Rule 203, as published in the eCFR, is precise about the three alternative conditions a broker must satisfy before accepting a short sale order or executing a short sale for its own account. It must have borrowed the security, or entered into a good faith arrangement to borrow it; or have reasonable grounds to believe that the security can be borrowed so that it can be delivered on the date delivery is due; and, in all cases, document its compliance with this obligation. This documentation is not a side formality: it is an integral part of the regulatory obligation and can be examined during an inspection.

The exception granted to market makers

Rule 203 provides a notable exception for market makers. Short sales effected by a market maker in connection with bona fide market making activity in the security concerned are exempt from the prior locate obligation. This exception recognizes that market makers must be able to continuously quote bid and ask prices, including when they sell short temporarily to provide market liquidity, without each transaction requiring an individual locate verification.

Close-out timeframes for a failure to deliver

The close-out rule, codified at Rule 204 (17 CFR 242.204), requires that a failure to deliver, whether resulting from a long sale or a short sale, be closed out no later than the beginning of regular trading hours on the settlement day following the settlement date. The broker must then borrow or purchase securities of like kind and quantity to close out the position. A more flexible regime applies when the failure to deliver is demonstrably the result of a long sale: the participant then has an extended deadline, up to the third consecutive settlement day following the settlement date, to close out the position, provided this can be demonstrated on its own books and records.

A separate and stricter regime applies to so-called threshold securities, meaning securities that show a high and persistent level of failures to deliver. If a failure to deliver on a threshold security persists for thirteen consecutive settlement days, the participant must immediately close out that position by purchasing securities of like kind and quantity, without waiting for a new settlement cycle.

Close-out timeframes under Rule 204 of Regulation SHO
SituationClose-out deadlineReference text
Failure to deliver, general ruleBeginning of the settlement day following the settlement dateRule 204, 17 CFR 242.204
Failure to deliver resulting from a demonstrated long saleBeginning of the third consecutive settlement day following the settlement dateRule 204, 17 CFR 242.204
Failure to deliver on a threshold security, 13-day persistenceImmediate close-outRule 203, 17 CFR 242.203

Naked short selling and interpreting a high short interest

The notion of naked short selling comes up frequently in discussions about Regulation SHO. It generally refers to selling short without having borrowed the securities needed to ensure delivery. This overlaps with the kind of situation readers may have encountered in the Wall Street Weekly Recap, where a heavily shorted stock draws particular attention from the market. The locate requirement and the close-out rule are designed precisely to regulate this practice, though the sources used here do not support any claim about what a large position or a high percentage of short interest in a stock represents on its own.

Frequently asked questions about the SHO locate requirement

Does the SHO locate requirement ban all short selling?

No, it does not. It conditions the acceptance or execution of a short sale order on a prior check by the broker: the broker must have borrowed the security, entered into a good faith arrangement to borrow it, or have reasonable grounds to believe it can be delivered on the settlement date, in accordance with Rule 203.

What happens if a security is not delivered by the settlement date?

The broker must close out the failure to deliver within the timeframes set by Rule 204: no later than the beginning of the settlement day following the settlement date in the general case, or up to the third consecutive settlement day if the position is demonstrably the result of a long sale.

Do all brokers have to locate a security before every short sale?

Not in every case. Rule 203 provides an exception for market makers when the short sale is part of bona fide market making activity in the security concerned.

Does a high short interest on a stock mean there is illegal short selling?

The texts of Rule 203 and Rule 204 make no such link: these are compliance mechanisms concerning the prior locate of a security and the close-out of a failure to deliver, distinct from the measurement of the level of short interest in a stock.