The J-Com error refers to the accidental sale of 610,000 J-Com shares at 1 yen apiece by a Mizuho Securities trader, on December 8, 2005 on the Tokyo Stock Exchange, instead of the intended sale of a single share at 610,000 yen. The incident cost Mizuho Securities 40 billion yen, according to Japan’s Financial Services Agency (Japan Times, December 23, 2005).
What the trader meant to do and what was actually entered
On December 8, 2005, the day of J-Com’s initial public offering, an online recruiting company, a Mizuho Securities trader was supposed to sell a single J-Com share at a price of 610,000 yen. The order actually transmitted to the Tokyo Stock Exchange system reversed the two figures: it offered to sell 610,000 shares at 1 yen each. The Japan Times reports the exact mechanics of the reversal: a Mizuho Securities trader tried to sell 610,000 shares of job recruiting company J-Com Co. at 1 yen apiece instead of selling 1 share of the company for 610,000 yen (Japan Times).
Why the volume exceeded any real possibility of delivery
The scale of the error also stemmed from the size of J-Com itself. The company had only 14,000 shares outstanding at the time of its listing, a figure with no relation to the 600,000 shares the order offered to sell. The Guardian summarizes it this way: a “sell” order was mistakenly placed for 600,000 shares, despite the fact the company concerned, J-Com, only had 14,000 shares in issue (The Guardian, December 9, 2005). Mizuho was thus offering to deliver roughly forty-three times more shares than the company had ever issued.
The price drop followed by the late-session rebound
The arrival of this massive sell order caused J-Com’s price to fall by the daily limit set by market authorities, 100,000 yen, bringing it down to around 572,000 yen within thirty minutes of the opening, a level already below the IPO price of 610,000 yen. The Guardian states: the error caused J-Com’s share price to slide by the daily limit set by market authorities, 100,000 yen (475 pounds), to 572,000 yen in 30 minutes of trading, well below the IPO issue price of 610,000 yen. However, the shares recovered later, ending the day at 772,000 yen. The stock therefore closed the session well above its listing price, after a morning of sharp decline tied solely to the erroneous order.
Why the system refused to cancel the order
Mizuho Securities attempted to cancel the erroneous order, without success against the Tokyo Stock Exchange system. This failure had consequences that went beyond financial matters: the president and other executives of the Tokyo Stock Exchange resigned, as this incident added to other computer failures that had occurred earlier in the year. The Japan Times states it explicitly: it also forced the president and other executives at the Tokyo Stock Exchange to resign over their failure to cancel the erroneous trade and for other computer system problems that struck earlier in the year. Japan’s Financial Services Agency also issued Mizuho Securities a business improvement order, a first for this type of order entry error: the financial watchdog also ordered the major brokerage to submit business-improvement plans by Jan. 20 […] It is the first time the agency has issued a business improvement order to a brokerage for a stock-order mistake.
The nearly ten-year lawsuit between Mizuho and the Tokyo Stock Exchange
Mizuho Securities subsequently sued the Tokyo Stock Exchange, blaming its technical failure to block the erroneous order. The Tokyo Stock Exchange’s official document summarizes the initial claim: Mizuho Securities filed a lawsuit against TSE in the Tokyo District Court claiming damages of approximately JPY 41.5 billion with respect to an erroneous order for the sale of shares of J-COM Co., Ltd. placed on December 8, 2005 (Tokyo Stock Exchange, press release, September 4, 2015). The dispute ended in September 2015, nearly ten years after the events, when Japan’s Supreme Court dismissed the appeals from both parties. The Tokyo High Court ruling of July 24, 2013, which had already reduced the amount owed in favor of the Tokyo Stock Exchange, thus became final: the Supreme Court has issued an order to dismiss the appeals and refused to accept the case as the final appellate court. As such, the judgment of the Tokyo High Court issued on July 24, 2013 became final and binding.
What this account does not specify
The sources consulted do not specify the details of the entry control mechanisms that the Tokyo Stock Exchange changed following this incident, nor the identity of the trader responsible for the error, nor the exact circumstances of the entry.
| Date | Element | Value |
|---|---|---|
| December 8, 2005 | J-Com shares outstanding | 14,000 |
| December 8, 2005 | Shares mistakenly offered for sale | 610,000 |
| December 8, 2005 | J-Com price roughly 30 minutes after opening | 572,000 yen |
| December 8, 2005 | J-Com closing price | 772,000 yen |
| December 23, 2005 | Announced loss for Mizuho Securities | 40 billion yen |
| September 4, 2015 | Final outcome of Mizuho vs. Tokyo Stock Exchange dispute | appeals dismissed by Supreme Court |
Frequently asked questions about the J-Com error
What exactly is the J-Com error?
The J-Com error is the accidental sale of 610,000 J-Com shares at 1 yen apiece by a Mizuho Securities trader on December 8, 2005, when the intent was to sell a single share at 610,000 yen. The erroneous volume far exceeded the 14,000 shares actually outstanding for J-Com that day.
Why could Mizuho Securities not cancel the order?
The sources report that the Tokyo Stock Exchange failed to cancel the erroneous transaction, a failure that led to the resignation of the president and other exchange executives, in addition to other computer problems that occurred that same year. The technical detail of this failed cancellation is not specified in the sources consulted.
What was the financial consequence for Mizuho Securities?
Japan’s Financial Services Agency put the loss suffered by Mizuho Securities at 40 billion yen and imposed a business improvement order on it, with a plan to be submitted by January 20, 2006, a first for an order entry error.
How did the legal dispute end?
Mizuho Securities sued the Tokyo Stock Exchange for approximately 41.5 billion yen in damages. The dispute concluded in September 2015, when Japan’s Supreme Court dismissed the appeals from both parties, making the Tokyo High Court ruling of July 2013, which had reduced the amount owed, final.
Other technical failures have marked the history of markets, as detailed in this article on the Knight Capital glitch, or this one on US market circuit breakers, the mechanisms meant to limit this kind of runaway move on American markets.
